Home / Be The Change / Dakota 38 — 154 Years Ago Today, Govt Carried Out the Largest Mass Execution in US History

Dakota 38 — 154 Years Ago Today, Govt Carried Out the Largest Mass Execution in US History


Mankato, MN — December 26 marks the 154th anniversary of the largest mass execution in U.S. government history — 38 Dakota men were publicly hanged in Mankato, Minnesota, in 1862 for their role in the war between the two sovereign nations.

Historians and attorneys examining the history of this gruesome act by the State say the justification lacked for the execution of these warriors — and the United States government did not provide a fair trial.

Considering the U.S.’ history in dealing with those indigenous to the land, that assessment hardly comes as a shock — also unsurprising is its lingering trauma on the Dakota people and other Native American Nations to this day.

“The trials of the Dakota were conducted unfairly in a variety of ways,” noted University of Minnesota associate professor, Carol Chomsky. “The evidence was sparse, the tribunal was biased, the defendants were unrepresented in unfamiliar proceedings conducted in a foreign language, and authority for convening the tribunal was lacking. More fundamentally, neither the Military Commission nor the reviewing authorities recognized that they were dealing with the aftermath of a war fought with a sovereign nation and that the men who surrendered were entitled to treatment in accordance with that status.”

For six weeks during the late summer of 1862, a war raged between members of the Dakota nation and the U.S. military in southern Minnesota, largely due to broken treaty promises — and particularly over promises of sufficient food and supplies for the Indigenous peoples.

Many Dakota, however, chose not to participate in the battle, instead, either staying away or protecting white settlers from their enraged brethren.

According to one albeit biased website on the history of the war:

“There were a number of factors which contributed to the Dakota Uprising in 1862. Life was changing for the Dakota as both fur-bearing and game animals, upon which they depended, were getting scarce. It is likely that the Dakota had expected that they would be able to live off the proceeds from selling their land to the U.S. government, via the treaties of 1851 and 1858, but it was not working out that way.”

In fact, the government had broken a number of promises, but appeared to be playing favorites with those willing to bend to its specific goals, as another source on the topic reported:

“Hunger was widespread throughout Dakota lands in Minnesota.  Since crops had been poor in 1861, the Dakota had little food stored for the ‘starving winter’ of 1861-62. Their reservation supported no game, and increasing settlement off the reservation meant more competition with Euro-Americans hunting for meat. Reports about government agents’ corrupt treatment of the Dakota were ignored.  Factionalism continued among the Dakota, as those who maintained traditional ways saw that only those who had acculturated were reaping government support. Finally, a delayed treaty payment made traders nervous, and many of them cut off credit to Dakota hunters. Indian Agent Thomas Galbraith refused to distribute food to the Dakota, and though Dakota farmers shared food with their relatives throughout the summer of 1862, it wasn’t enough.”

Of course the situation looked particularly grim from the Dakota perspective, as the government had corralled the populace into a specific area, and settlers continued to flood the previously sparsely populated area. Taoyateduta, or Little Crow — Mdewakanton Dakota — penned a letter to Galbraith that year, cautioning what might be on the horizon should their situation not be alleviated:

“We have waited a long time. The money is ours but we cannot get it. We have no food but here these stores are filled with food. We ask that you, the agent, make some arrangement so we can get food from the stores, or else we may take our own way to keep ourselves from starving. When men are hungry, they help themselves.”

Fighting shortly ensued — and all told, hundreds of Dakota, settlers, and U.S. soldiers died over the course of the war — and hundreds of Dakota warriors were arrested and sentenced to  death, primarily for killing civilians not involved in fighting.

President Abraham Lincoln ultimately spared the lives of the majority of the accused — except for 38 men.

An utterly gruesome description of the public hanging appeared in the New York Times shortly after it occurred, stating, as cited by the Minnesota Star Tribune,

“Their caps were now drawn over their eyes, and the halter placed about their necks. Several of them feeling uncomfortable, made severe efforts to loosen the rope, and some, after the most dreadful contortions, partially succeeded. The signal to cut the rope was three taps of the drum. All things being ready, the first tap was given, when the poor wretches made such frantic efforts to grasp each other’s hands, that it was agony to behold them. Each one shouted out his name, that his comrades might know he was there. The second tap resounded on the air. The vast multitude were breathless with the awful surroundings of this solemn occasion. Again the doleful tap breaks on the stillness of the scene. Click! goes the sharp ax, and the descending platform leaves the bodies of thirty-eight human beings dangling in the air.”

To commemorate that startling event — and to attempt to begin a collective recovery of the historical grief associated with it and generally the actions of settlers and the U.S. government against Indigenous Americans — 38 people each year ride on horseback across North Dakota and Minnesota to Mankato.

“The past is really, really traumatic,” said Sarah Weston, member of the Flandreau Santee Sioux Tribe and co-director of Dakota 38, a film chronicling and discussing the ride. “But we’re going to reach our hand out and say that we forgive. Because when you’re not in a forgiveness place, you’re linked to that person or that trauma for the rest of your life, all day long. And so by forgiving we’re no longer linked to that.”

This year, some of the riders left directly from encampments opposing the Dakota Access Pipeline near the Missouri River in North Dakota — where scabs have been picked once again for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, who are currently in a desperate race to protect their drinking water supply.

Also unshockingly, that battle — more than a century and a half later — also concerns broken treaties and promises from a government seemingly callous to anything but its own interests.

Remembering this lurid and wholly unjustified public killing — the mass execution — of 38 people is absolutely imperative in presenting a more accurate depiction of the bloody and ghastly history of this country straight. Without the knowledge of what’s actually occurred over time, there can be no way for us all to move forward from a place of understanding to ensure such atrocities will not repeat in a new and potentially equally horrific manner.

If we don’t learn the lessons of history, we’re doomed to repeat them — but if we never know the actual history, such preventive measures are impossible.

READ MORE:  Next-generation Crowd Control: "Calmative Agents" Will Put Entire Protests Under Sedation

The full version of Dakota 38 can be seen below:

  • James Latham

    This country goes around the world accusing other nations of human right violations. Wonderful US history books cover none of the slaughter and how the government broke over 200 treaties. Instead we read about the great Generals who won the battles against these savages. Disgusting the US does not admit to the genocide of the American Indians which killed more than Hitler killing of the Jews.

    • David Daisy May Boldock

      Genocide of approximately 100 Million James, so far surpasses all the casualties of WW11 alone.
      I concur with all you state. 🙂

    • Selah Taylor

      Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee by Dee Brown covers some of the atrocities committed by our government. It is where my initial knowledge of native american genocide came from.

    • JayGoldenBeach

      The U.S. is a Bermuda Triangle for human rights.

  • susan.ward

    I’ve made $84 ,000 up to now this holiday season working online however I am only a full time student . I’m implementing an internet business money making opportunity I heard about and even I’ve made such decent earnings . It’s undoubtedly user-friendly so I am just so very happy that I discovered out regarding it . The possibility of success within this is unlimited . Here’s what exactly I do>>> http://secure81.weebly.com

  • QV3

    Oh, the silence from American commenters is so telling. Like cockroaches they flee into the dark cavern of evil as the light shines exposing their Crimes Against the Original Native American Indians, while arrogantly living on STOLEN LAND.
    While continuing to PUNISH the Original Inhabitants into apartheid concentration camps called ‘reservations’. While strutting round the globe hollering Democracy, Human Rights, Right to Protect.


    Russell Means: Welcome to the American Reservation Prison Camp (Full Length)

  • zipcdr
  • R.G.Weiser

    there is no statute of limitations on wrongful death lawsuits

  • All done in the pursuit of bigger profits.

    Owned & Operated

  • peggy.summerlin

    I’ve made $84 ,000 to this point this year working via internet and I’m a full time student . I’m benefiting from a home based business money making opportunity I observed and even I’ve earned such type of good money . It is undoubtedly user-friendly not to mention I’m just very glad that I discovered out about it . The potential with this is end-less . Here’s everything I do>>> http://secure65.weebly.com

    • Boxer36

      Get your greedy, dishonest, wretched self off this stream. This is a place of compassion and concern, not a grifters paradise. Take your scam elsewhere you sociopath.

  • doucyet

    It is with shame and disgrace that this country was founded. The broken promises to the Native Americans who we befriended and then slaughtered. The red stripes, their blood, will forever be a stain on that precious flag of the United States…..

    • permalink

      If one cannot defend one’s property, then one does not deserve to hold it.

      • doucyet


      • Jamie Hall

        I think I might like to have a nice little piece of vacation property. You won’t mind if I come and forcibly take it from you, will you? After all, if you can’t defend it, then you don’t really deserve to have it. That is what you said. Right?

        • permalink

          I own mountain property in Colorado you could squat on right now. What do you have to say now?

          • Selah Taylor

            How come all you fucking cowards hide behind fake names?

          • permalink

            How does anyone know **Selah Taylor** is your name?

          • Selah Taylor

            So your real name is permalink? A lot of people know that, I’m not a coward that hides behind a fake name.

          • permalink

            You did not answer my question.

        • permalink

          And the funny thing is it will cost you about $50,000 just in developmental costs if I simply walked away.

          The joke is on you, ha ha ha.

      • Steve Rusk

        They can take your property or they can just ruin it and there’s not a damn thing you can do about it. If you have something the moneyed interests that government protects and serves wants or you’re in their way, then you have no rights. They built a wind farm around my property and it lost 80% of it’s value, there was no compensation. Resistance, complaints, even evidence was futile. Had I taken up arms against them, law enforcement would have executed me and the media would have dismissed my execution as that of just another kook with a gun. For those of us compelled by “Force of Law” to support this tyranny in Amerika, resistance is futile no matter what your race or color. 10038 Elm Sugar Rd. Scott, Ohio 45891 Google it

  • AlvinBr

    This isn’t studied in AP history courses, is it?

  • permalink

    “where scabs have been picked once again for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, who are currently in a desperate race to protect their drinking water supply”

    A bit out-of-context…

    The current water intake for the tribe is located at Ft Yates, ND and is beyond functional repair. A completely new water intake is built at Mobridge, SD for the tribe. It is too bad the author of this fictional piece could not include that factual item.

    • Selah Taylor

      Go drink some oil and show the rest of us how it’s done. Take a video.

      • permalink

        It appears you don’t know what you are talking about. I doubt you have ever been in North Dakota…

        • Selah Taylor

          I know that humans can’t live on oil, so yes I do know what I’m talking about. Send in that video, prove me wrong.

          • permalink

            Have you ever been to Ft Yates, ND or Mobridge, SD? My first question should have been can you read a map…

            And why would I want to drink any oil? The DAPL will be horizontally drilled in 90+ feet below the bottom of the river. You would know that if you read the 1,100+ page environmental assessment on the USACE website.

            And why would I want to drink from there?

          • Selah Taylor

            Have you by chance heard of the Oglalla reservoir? Google it. They propose running the pipeline across it, look that up. Now look up the number of pipeline spills there were in 2016. They run this pipeline there we are fucked, because plants won’t grow on toxic sludge either. Look up America’s breadbasket.
            Can you read a map?

          • permalink

            Are you certain you are not talking about the **Ogallala Aquifer**? I could not find any reference to “Oglalla reservoir”…

            There are already numerous pipelines crossing the Ogallala Aquifer. The aquifer has portions in eight states (South Dakota, Nebraska, Wyoming, Colorado, Kansas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, and Texas).



            That area is hardly “America’s breadbasket”. Wheat has been the primary crop grown there. Now corn has displaced wheat for ethanol in the last few years, as corn pays a better price than wheat. Problem w/ corn being grown is it is depleting the aquifer because corn needs more water than wheat.

            And I could care less about how many pipeline spills there are per year. If we took all the cars and trucks off the roads we would not have any traffic accidents either…

  • Marcia Everett

    You can add the millions of Africans on to that list. The European Americans made so many false agreements, hat brought death and starvation to people of color. And now they have elected themselves.

  • Steve Rusk

    Justice in America, not all that different today, same hypocrisy just a little less obvious.

  • JayGoldenBeach

    The U.S. govt. is a vampire with an insatiable thirst for war-spilled blood.

    “…liberty and justice for all” is just a cynical sound bite.