Skip to main content

FARMINGTON, N.M. — In yet another tragic example of the dangerous consequences of police incompetence, a New Mexico man was gunned down in his own home by the very people who are sworn to protect and serve. The callous actions of the Farmington Police Department are chillingly reminiscent of the Andrew Finch case, where an innocent man was similarly killed in his own home, proving that the militarization of American police forces continues to pose a significant threat to our civil liberties.

Late Wednesday night, Farmington police officers responded to a domestic violence call on Valley View Avenue. However, in a colossal display of negligence, the officers showed up at the wrong house. Despite announcing their presence, the officers failed to ensure that the homeowner, 52-year-old Robert Dotson, was informed of their identity. Instead of attempting to de-escalate the situation, these supposed "peacekeepers" escalated tensions to a deadly level.

When Dotson approached his door, he had no idea who the intruders were so he armed himself with a handgun, the officers opened fire without hesitation. This hair-trigger response from the police is a symptom of the increasingly militarized nature of American law enforcement, where the slightest hint of danger prompts a lethal reaction.

Dotson was struck by at least one round, and in the chaos that ensued, his wife also armed herself and opened fire from the doorway. It was only after the officers returned fire that she realized they were, in fact, police officers. When the dust settled, Robert Dotson lay dead in his own home, a victim of trigger-happy law enforcement.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended for You

The Finch case, which occurred a few years ago, echoes this same horrifying pattern of police negligence and excessive force. In that instance, Andrew Finch was also gunned down in his own home after police responded to a false report of a hostage situation. It is evident that these cases are not isolated incidents, but rather a symptom of a systemic problem that permeates our nation's law enforcement agencies.

The Farmington police officers involved in this tragedy have not yet been identified, but it is imperative that they be held accountable for their reckless actions. Body camera footage of the incident is expected to be released in the coming days, and we can only hope that it will provide further evidence to support the need for sweeping changes in American policing.

As we continue to report on the egregious actions of law enforcement agencies across the country, it is crucial that we also strive to inform and empower the public. The cases of Robert Dotson and Andrew Finch are harrowing reminders of the consequences of unchecked police power, and it is incumbent upon all of us to ensure that their deaths are not in vain. In order to prevent further tragedies, we must demand transparency, accountability, and an end to the culture of fear and aggression that has become synonymous with American policing.